We have an accountability crisis. A 2025 Culture Partners study found that 80% of employees say feedback only happens when something goes wrong, and most confuse accountability with blame. No wonder leaders struggle. Accountability has become synonymous with punishment and “being held accountable.” However, perhaps the single issue isn’t accountability, but rather a multifaceted issue of clarity, mindset and training.
Here’s a snapshot of the four stages of accountability breakdown, along with practical ways leaders can move from avoidance to alignment, where coaching replaces criticism and clarity replaces confusion.
The four phases of accountability breakdown
Phase 1: Avoidance
Leaders postpone the tough talk. Fear, lack of skill or hoping the problem disappears only makes tension build.
Phase 2: The conversation
Eventually, the leader has the talk. To their surprise, it goes smoother than expected. Relief sets in, even pride.
Phase 3: Temporary improvement
The employee makes short-term changes. The leader breathes a sigh of relief, believing the storm has passed.
Phase 4: Regression
Old habits creep back in. The same issues resurface. Resentment builds. The leader wonders, “Should I try again?” Document? Escalate to HR?
Distinguish responsibility and accountability
In working with hundreds of clients over 20 years, I have noticed several recurring patterns. The terms “responsibility” and “accountability” are used interchangeably. What I can say with certainty is that responsibility and accountability are distinct, yet both are necessary.
- Responsibility is about ownership. It’s of the heart.
- Accountability is about measurement. It’s of the head.
Here’s another important distinction: Accountability requires a witness, which is another person, for example, a leader, who confirms the measurements. You can’t be accountable without a witness. There is no such thing as “personal accountability.” There is, however, personal responsibility, which is about taking ownership. When people take ownership, they actually want measurement, and they want a coach, mentor or witness to confirm their success.
A common problem in corporations is the lack of responsibility in applying. Accountability (measurement) without personal responsibility creates mere compliance. I can’t say this enough: Change the corporate language to differentiate between responsibility and accountability, and you’ll find every single leak.
Pro tip: When the head and heart work together, accountability feels like alignment, not punishment.
Eliminate blame
The only way to eliminate blame from your culture is for the leadership to adopt a mindset and practice of 100% responsibility. A blaming mindset from any leader, especially at the top, cannot produce responsible or accountable employees. Without a responsible mindset, blame takes center stage, and accountability becomes something to avoid. An important skill is learning how to identify irresponsible language, allowing you to eliminate blame. Besides name-calling and gossip, here are some common yet less recognized examples.
Common phrases that undermine accountability:
- “That’s not my job.”
- “I assumed you knew…”
- “They dropped the ball.”
- “I didn’t have time.”
- “It’s above my pay grade.”
- “No one told me.”
- “We’ve always done it this way.”
Some leaders may justify these statements by saying, “Well, it’s the truth.” That’s how you know there’s a responsibility problem and not an accountability problem.
Pro tip: In any area where you see recurring conflict, you’ll find an absence of responsibility and an abundance of blame.
Clarity comes before accountability
According to Gallup, only 45% of employees are aware of what’s expected of them. Without clarity, accountability is impossible. Most employees answer “no” to the question: I know what my boss expects from me at work.
Culture Partners reports that 85% of employees aren’t sure what their organizations are trying to achieve, and one-third say priorities change frequently. Confusion is the enemy of accountability.
Pro tip: In accountable cultures, employees feel free to ask for clarification about tasks and priorities.
Teach managers how to coach
The Talent Strategy Group reports that coaching conversations aren’t happening because managers lack skills and often, the right mindset. When managers view performance issues as “catch and punish” instead of “coach and support,” accountability feels unsafe.
Pro tip: Accountability grows when managers view performance conversations as opportunities to coach, rather than confront.
Quick action checklist
Leaders can start strengthening accountability this quarter by:
- Defining responsibility (ownership) vs. accountability (measurement).
- Auditing culture for blame-language.
- Training managers to coach, not catch.
Building a culture of accountability doesn’t happen overnight, but it doesn’t have to be complicated. Accountability without blame is a competitive advantage. The question is: Are your leaders driving accountability or waiting for an accountability crisis to arise?
Opinions expressed by SmartBrief contributors are their own.
____________________________________
Take advantage of SmartBrief’s FREE email newsletters on leadership and business transformation, among the company’s more than 250 industry-focused newsletters.
