How to Lead When the Room Panics: 7 Essential Strategies

CRISIS doesn’t create leaders; it reveals them. It strips away the trappings of title and tenure and shines a spotlight on judgment, courage, and decisiveness. And while no sane executive welcomes a crisis, the best don’t waste one either. Crisis is the ultimate leadership stress test. If you want to pass it—and elevate your organization in the process—here are seven lessons you’d better take seriously.

1. Smoke Usually Means Fire

Ignore the early warning signs, and you’ll soon be standing in the ashes of your own inattention. Every crisis starts small. A dip in customer satisfaction. A missed deliverable. A bizarre memo from compliance. Pay attention to these flares. If you don’t, they become grenades with the pins pulled. Leaders don’t have the luxury of surprise. If something feels off, it probably is. Probe early. Intervene sooner. Make a nuisance of yourself—your board will thank you later.

2. Don’t Lose Altitude or Airspeed

Pilots live by this. Leaders should, too.

Altitude is perspective. It’s your ability to rise above the noise and see where the business is really headed. Lose it, and you’re flying blind.
Airspeed is momentum. If your team stalls, if decisions drag, if execution slows, gravity wins.
Ideas are your engine. Without innovation and creative problem-solving, you’re dead stick—no thrust, no options.

Want to survive a crisis? Keep one eye on the horizon and one hand on the throttle—and make sure someone’s thinking clearly.

3. Face Reality or be Replaced by Someone Who Will

Leaders who sugarcoat bad news don’t build trust—they build exits. Denial is not a strategy. When the Tylenol crisis hit Johnson & Johnson in 1982, their leaders didn’t issue platitudes or duck responsibility. They pulled $100 million worth of products off shelves, stopped production, and offered full exchanges. Painful? Absolutely. But it saved the company—and became a business school case study on how to lead in disaster. You don’t need a cyanide capsule to tell the truth. Own it. Communicate it. Fix it.

4. Prepare as if it Matters (Because it Does)

You don’t train for the marathon in the middle of the race. And yet, I watch leaders “practice bleed”—agonizing over hypotheticals, spinning their wheels in the name of preparation that’s neither practical nor actionable. Instead, do this:

Monitor cash as if it were oxygen—because it is.
Create a crisis response team with decision-making authority.
Map out the top ten disasters that could hit your organization. Plan responses now.
Build strong external relationships before you need them.
Maintain a real-time contact list of every stakeholder who matters.

Preparation beats panic. Every. Time.

5. Be Realistic Without Becoming Fatalistic

Optimism isn’t denial—it’s discipline. It’s knowing how bad things are and leading anyway. Don’t declare false victories or pretend a new coat of paint will keep the ship afloat. Be honest about what you are facing. Share what you know and what you don’t. But don’t ever say, “It can’t get worse.” Because it can, and you’ll sound like a fool when it does. Instead, project confidence in your team’s ability to adapt and overcome. Resilience starts at the top.

6. Control the Microphone

In a crisis, silence is not golden—it’s cowardice. If you’re not filling the information void, someone else will. Employees, clients, media—they will all be watching and wondering. So, speak. Clearly. Often. Honestly. And strategically. Ask yourself daily:

What must happen today to turn the tide?
What can I clarify or simplify?
What are people afraid of—and what real reassurance can I offer?
What do I need to say that no one else will?

Don’t let PR run the narrative. You’re the leader. Act like it.

7. Don’t Let the Media Outmaneuver You

The media is not your enemy. But if you treat them as if they are, they’ll become one. “No comment” is not strategy—it’s surrender. Instead:

Be quick. Delay signals guilt or confusion.
Be honest. Spin is dead.
Be consistent. Focus on three key messages and repeat them relentlessly.
Don’t minimize the crisis—or compare it to something worse. That’s not perspective; it’s evasion.
Never blame the victims. Take responsibility, even if someone else messed up.

And remember: accessibility earns credibility. If you vanish during good times, don’t expect goodwill when things go south.

Machiavelli got it right: never waste the opportunity of a good crisis. Because crisis will either bury you or it will catapult you to the next level of leadership. You decide. Leading through uncertainty doesn’t require perfection. It requires presence, perspective, and the guts to do what’s right when it’s hard.

Don’t wait for the smoke to clear. Get in front of it. That’s what real leaders do.

* * *

Dr. Linda Henman is an advisor, speaker, coach, and author or co-author of 11 books. She founded Henman Performance Group, a leadership consulting firm that works with C-suite leaders from organizations like Avon, Emerson Electric, Estee Lauder, Kraft, and Tyson Foods. Her work with executives is guided by her PhD research on how American POWS (including John McCain) maintained resilience by making pivotal decisions during their brutal imprisonment. Her strategies in decision-making to increase profitability, mergers & acquisitions, succession planning, and other issues have never failed. Her work with John Tyson helped land one of the most successful acquisitions in the twenty-first century. Her new book is Healthy Decisions: Critical Thinking Skills for Healthcare Executives. Learn more at Henmanperformancegroup.com

* * *